infiniband

512 GPUs at 400 Gb/s each is 205 Tb/s of injection bandwidth a two-tier fabric must carry with no oversubscribed link. The port arithmetic that gives 16 leaves and 8 spines, the rail wiring that keeps NCCL traffic one hop away, and the line where 900 GB/s of NVLink becomes 50 GB/s of InfiniBand.

Links that never come up and links that come up and flap are different faults with different causes. The reach change between 400G and 800G explains most first-time failures, and the counters separate the rest. The order to check, and the one physical measurement that settles it.

A rail-optimized fabric makes this fault findable because the eight rails are identical by construction, so any asymmetry is a defect. Bisecting by rail, then by switch, then by node, then by port narrows 512 links to one in four steps, and the counters say which of three physical causes it is.

Both run at the same port speed, so the discount is not buying slower hardware. It is buying a different operational model and a different failure mode, and whether that is worth 15 percent depends on what your team already runs and what the fabric has to carry.

Both carry RDMA at the same line rate. One arrives lossless because the transport was designed that way, the other becomes lossless only if a set of switch settings is correct on every port. What that difference costs in operations, what it saves in money and hiring, and the fleet size where the answer flips.

Two all-to-alls per layer across sixty layers is over a hundred collectives on the critical path of every decode step, each one small and latency-bound. The per-GPU volume worked out, the time on each link type, and why a single large NVLink domain changes the design rather than just improving it.